shopping mall, shops, shopping, architecture, people, building, city, modern, new, fashion, luxury, brand, sale, lifestyle, glass, steel, projects, supermarket, the interior of the, convenience, entertainment, house, the window, the website, exhibition, shopping mall, shopping mall, shopping mall, shopping mall, shopping mall, supermarket
Photo by AS_Photography on Pixabay

Retail Formats

Part of Retail expansion: how to assess store networks

Evaluating the intended role of smaller store formats

Assess smaller retail stores by customer task, range, replenishment costs and their effect on the wider network.

This is an editorial pen name used by the publication, not a claim of an independently verified personal identity. Original editorial credit: Desk Economics.

undefined

Smaller stores can serve specific shopping jobs, such as convenient access or a focused range. Australian examples include Woolworths Metro, pitched for convenience-led trips, and Coles Local, which includes supermarket conversions (The Sydney Morning Herald). These examples show intended roles, not commercial results: assess a format through store contribution and its effect on the network, not store count or sales density alone.

Identify the intended job of smaller store formats

Start with the target trip. Woolworths has pitched Metro as an alternative to a convenience store in densely populated locations such as train stations, stocking food that can be eaten on the run (The Sydney Morning Herald). Coles Local shows a conversion route: standard Coles supermarkets have been converted in Melbourne and Sydney; York Street in the CBD was the only new Coles Local store opened (The Sydney Morning Herald).

A Woolworths Metro is about a quarter (600 square metres) the size of a typical supermarket (2500 square metres) and stocks less than half the number of products (about 10,000 compared with 28,000) (The Sydney Morning Herald). These figures support assessing Metro as a narrower, convenience-oriented format; they do not establish its sales density or contribution.

In 2020, Wesfarmers announced that about half of Target Country stores, 52, were suited to conversion to smaller-format Kmart Hub stores, meeting criteria including location, population catchments and store size (Wesfarmers). This signals a planned regional footprint shaped by location and population catchments; it does not show how much either format sells or earns.

The same announcement notes that Target's costs included operating and supplying a large network of physical stores in regional Australia of varying sizes and ranges (Wesfarmers). That is a reminder to check labels before combining locations.

Wesfarmers' Smaller Format Strategy Highlights

Criteria for Kmart Hub Conversion
Location, population catchment, store size
Key Challenge in Regional Operations
Diverse store sizes and supply complexity

Assess the operating model against the intended role

Less floor area can mean lower total occupancy cost, but it may also mean less room for stock, narrower choice and more frequent replenishment. Compare rent and fit-out with staffing, delivery frequency, stock availability and the cost of handling returns or collections. If the small store depends on a nearby warehouse or distribution centre, include that support in the assessment.

Sales per square metre is especially easy to misread. A compact shop can have high density because it stocks only fast-moving lines. That does not establish a higher store contribution after labour and supply costs. Compare stores serving similar customer tasks, and consider contribution per location and per catchment alongside density.

Assess network effects against the intended role

A small format may extend reach into a catchment where a large store would be unsuitable. It may instead take sales from a nearby branch without creating much new demand.

Review changes in the surrounding network after opening, including online orders fulfilled or collected locally. A customer who visits the small store for an urgent item may later buy a broader range elsewhere; public aggregate data will rarely identify that path.

A format trial should therefore have an explicit test. Set the intended role, the comparable locations or catchments, the trading period and the measures of success before interpreting early sales. Check availability and repeat visits, not just opening-week traffic.

If the retailer later changes the assortment, hours or site size, treat the revised format as a new test rather than extending the first result without qualification.

Evaluating Smaller Store Formats: A Step-by-Step Approach

  1. Define the intended shopping jobe.g., convenience, urgent needs, urban access
  2. Compare operating model factorsrent, staffing, replenishment frequency, distribution support
  3. Assess network effectssales cannibalisation vs. new demand, online order fulfilment
  4. Set clear success metrics before launchavailability, repeat visits, contribution per location

More from Retail Formats