
Market Analysis
Retail expansion: how to assess store networks
Assess Australian retail network growth using openings, closures, store formats, comparable sales and the economics of new locations.
undefined
A retailer’s store network is expanding only when its capacity to serve customers grows in a useful way. A higher store count can help, but it does not show whether new sites earn their keep, existing stores lose sales to them, or a smaller format serves a different shopping trip. Start with the movement in the network, then test its effect on sales, costs and customer access.
Reported store counts take two shapes: a cumulative change measured from a base year, and a point-in-time total broken down by format. Neither shape shows on its own whether the network served more customers in the period just gone, so each needs its own reading.
Establish what changed
For each banner and reporting period, reconcile opening stores plus new stores minus closures to the closing count. Record conversions, acquisitions and transfers separately. A banner conversion, for example, changes the banner mix without necessarily adding a location to the group. A refurbishment changes a store’s offer but usually leaves the count unchanged.
According to Woolworths Group's submission to the ACCC, since 2008 ALDI has more than tripled its store network, growing by 425 stores; Woolworths increased its network by 326 and Coles by 107 in the same period. Treat these cumulative changes as a cross-check, not as a period-end count: a reconciliation still needs opening and closing counts for the period being assessed.
The definition of a store matters too. Check whether a reported network includes franchises, trade counters, pharmacies, clinics or locations outside Australia. Retailers may classify locations by format or ownership; adding unlike locations into one total can conceal the change a reader is trying to measure.
Scope is part of the count. Wesfarmers' 2024 Annual Report describes Bunnings as the leading retailer of home improvement and lifestyle products in Australia and New Zealand, and a major supplier to project builders, commercial tradespeople and the housing industry.
Wesfarmers' 2024 Annual Report says that, at the end of the period, there were 286 warehouses, 65 smaller format stores and 31 trade centres in the Bunnings network, as well as 15 Tool Kit Depot stores and 116 Beaumont Tiles stores. The same report states that Target operates 124 stores and employs approximately 10,000 team members across Australia. Record the formats separately: the snapshot shows network types, not which sites opened or closed in the period.
| Measure | Question it answers | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Gross openings | How many locations entered the network? | Says nothing about closures or trading quality. |
| Net change | How did the closing count move? | Can hide substantial openings and closures. |
| Renewals | How many existing sites were changed? | Does not establish a sales or profit uplift. |
| Comparable sales | How did the eligible existing base trade? | Depends on the retailer’s eligibility rules. |
Connect sites to demand
A proposed store needs a defined customer role. It might shorten travel time, serve a growing residential area, offer a faster top-up shop or support order collection. Each role implies a different catchment, assortment and operating cost. The relevant question is how much demand the network gains after allowing for sales diverted from nearby stores and digital channels.
Evaluate the catchment at the level where the decision is made. Population and traffic indicate opportunity, but neither measures purchases on its own. Look at competing offers, access at the intended opening hours, local shopping patterns and the retailer’s existing coverage.
Woolworths Group told the ACCC that it most commonly competes with Coles, or those engaged in developing sites for Coles, for large format freehold and leasehold sites, because of the similarity of their full line supermarket formats.
Woolworths Group's submission to the ACCC says its Metro stores require significantly less floor space than full line supermarkets and are more often positioned in urban, built up areas to cater for customer convenience. Use that description to frame a format-specific catchment test, rather than assuming a smaller store competes for the same trips as a full-line site.
Then compare the expected incremental sales and contribution with the rent, fit-out, labour, replenishment and ongoing upkeep required. A busy site can still be a poor addition if it mainly shifts sales from another store at higher cost.
Read sales against store age
New stores rarely provide a clean comparison with established ones from their first trading week. Opening dates, seasonal peaks, launch activity and the time needed to build repeat custom all affect the result. Group new sites into opening cohorts and compare like periods, formats and catchments.
Review sales per trading week and, where area is comparable, per square metre; then examine gross margin and store contribution. A sales measure alone does not show whether the site covers its operating costs.
Total sales growth and comparable sales growth answer different questions. The difference between them is not, by itself, a published measure of sales from new stores: the two measures can have distinct coverage, and total sales can move for other reasons. Read the retailer’s definition before attributing any gap to openings.
Treat format changes and closures as network decisions
A smaller store may reach customers a warehouse or full supermarket cannot serve efficiently. It may also carry fewer products, need frequent replenishment or rely on a nearby larger site for range and fulfilment. Compare it with the customer task it is designed for, rather than assuming that more sales per square metre means a better business.
Small format supermarkets are already widespread: Coles Local, ALDI, ALDI Corner Store, Woolworths Metro and IGA, among others, all use smaller retail sites (Woolworths Group submission to the ACCC). Size separates the formats further, as a full line Woolworths supermarket is significantly larger than an IGA or ALDI store and three to four times smaller than a Costco store.
A closure can remove an unproductive lease, reflect a conversion or follow a change in local demand. It can also reduce access and shift costs elsewhere in the network. Quarterly network disclosures may report gross openings and net movement by business line.
Such figures establish reported movement; they do not, by themselves, explain each site decision. Check the accompanying explanation and subsequent trading before calling a closure a success or failure.
Australian Supermarket Format Size Comparison
- CostcoThree to four times larger than full-line Woolworths
- Full-line Woolworths supermarketSignificantly larger than IGA or ALDI
- IGA / ALDI storeSmaller retail site
- Woolworths MetroRequires significantly less floor space than full-line supermarkets
Make the assessment repeatable
Use the same short record for each reporting period. It should cover the opening and closing count by format, gross openings, closures, conversions and renewals, the retailer’s comparable-sales definition, the age of new-store cohorts, and the evidence for incremental network contribution. Separate announced targets from sites actually opened. If a retailer changes its reporting boundaries, restate the earlier base where possible and label any comparison that cannot be made cleanly.
The strongest expansion case is a consistent one: the new location serves a distinct demand, the mature network remains healthy, and the additional sales justify the full cost of operating and maintaining the footprint. At period end, reconcile the site list to the reported count and flag movements whose classification has changed.
In this guide
- Reading a retailer's store expansion planCheck store targets against secured sites, actual openings, renewals and trading evidence when assessing an Australian retailer's expansion plan.
- Comparing new-store sales with mature-store performanceCompare new retail stores with mature sites using cohorts, comparable-sales definitions and network contribution without overstating public data.
- Evaluating the intended role of smaller store formatsAssess smaller retail stores by customer task, range, replenishment costs and their effect on the wider network.
- Understanding closures in the context of a wider networkAssess retail store closures through net network change, conversions, customer access and the economics of the remaining stores.



